Learn to use AI at work, with Claude. Yes, at your 9-to-5 desk job. Free in the 9-5 Survivors Lab

Ask Flex / Performance reviews

Ask Flex

Can you challenge a performance review?

Usually, yes. In writing. With receipts.

What you write

"This is unfair and it isn't true. I work harder than anyone here."

"On the point about late reports: all 12 went out by the 5th. Dates attached."

What they read

"Upset. Nothing to check."

"A claim with a date. Let's look."

An example. Your company's process comes first, and HR can tell you what it is.

Flex's short answer

Usually yes, and the way that works is in writing, with receipts: ask HR what the process is, then answer each point you disagree with using a date and a fact, calmly. A reply that reads as a feeling gets filed, and a reply that reads as a list gets read.

✱ Flex's tips

Calm, dated, factual.

1

Ask for the process

HR or your handbook. One email.

2

Answer each point

One fact and one date per point.

3

Attach the receipts

Emails, dates, numbers. Not adjectives.

4

Sleep on it once

Send the calm version, tomorrow.

Try this in your own Claude or ChatGPT

Here's the part of my performance review I disagree with, with names and private numbers removed: [paste it]. Here are the facts and dates I have on each point, also with private details out: [list them]. Help me write a short, calm written response that answers each point with a fact and a date, no emotion, no blame. Then tell me what I should ask HR about the process before I send it.

Before you paste work stuff into any AI, check what your company allows.
Free tool

Review-Speak Decoder

Tap a phrase from your review. See what it usually means in plain words, and one calm thing to say back.

Decode a phrase
Flex the robot at his sunny office desk facing a blank review form as big as a billboard with only one box filled in that says Showed up, holding a pen with a chewed cap, while little Clawd peeks over the top edge of the form holding a tiny sticky note that says receipts
Inside the Lab

Learn this in the Lab, free

A free group where you learn to use Claude for the repeat parts of your job: email, reports, forms. Start with a 15-minute chat that maps what Claude can do in your job.

  • Free
  • No coding
  • Works in Claude
Start free on Skool
✱ What people ask
What does being under performance review mean?

Usually that your manager has concerns and wants to see a change over a set time. Ask what the specific concerns are and how they'll measure the change.

How do I write final feedback for a performance review?

Short and factual. Thank them, state what you agree with, answer what you don't with dates, and name one goal.

Where do I get AI help with the rest of my performance review?

Your wins as a list, the form's questions, one example per answer. Flex has a page on it.

✱ More from this pile: Performance reviews
From Nikki's blogFlex tells you how. Nikki tells you what it felt like. Read it on Clawd and Me. Read it →

Want to hand this to Claude?

Start in the Lab with the free 9-to-5 Job Triage: a 15-minute chat that maps what Claude can do in your job. Everything inside is free.

Start free on Skool